Collateral Damage and Aftermath
Jan. 23rd, 2012 04:38 pmLately I've been mulling over collateral damage and aftermath in stories. For some reason, watching action movies often makes me wonder about the collateral damage. Does anyone care about all the cars that are smashed, the buildings that are blown up? Who fixes everything after the villain has been defeated? Is the insurance responsible if your car is destroyed due to a heroic act of saving the neighborhood? I've been pondering the implications for many different settings.
Fantasy
So many heroes go on a quest, defeat the Dark Lord, and the story ends (more or less happily). After the Dark Lord has been defeated, then what? Who builds the country again? Most of these Dark Lords also have Dark Armies. If it is some sort of nasty that is morally bad (e.g. Tolkien's orcs), who hunts them down and kills them? If the army is composed, instead, of humans or some free-willed creatures, who decides who is good and who is bad? Are there military tribunals? To what degree is the army responsible for the actions ordered by the Dark Lord or his lieutenants? If there were many people pressed into military service, which ones were they (men, women, young, middle-aged, some mixture) and what effect has this had on the culture? What happens when these people go back? Are some of the military roving bands of outlaws, now?
If there is a rightful ruler, is he or she accepted by the general population? Is there an old constitution or declaration of rights that can be accepted, or does it have to be thought up from scratch? Who is in charge of this? Are there any judges, lawyers or politicians who weren't corrupted by the Dark Lord who can help, and if so, how can you tell if they've been corrupted or not? Has the Dark Lord mostly left local politics in place, or has he or she put their own people in charge everywhere? If so, has he or she merely deposed the good people, or killed them? Are there any bands of outlaws that are actually good (like Robin Hood), and how does one distinguish them from the nasty sort of outlaws, and having distinguished them, how does one bring them back into society?
Was there any other country whose army helped depose the Dark Lord? Will they expect some sort of reparations or such? Whose authority will they accept regarding a peace treaty? Are they leaving any occupying forces?
Has the Dark Lord accumulated gold or supplies at their fortress? What happens to these things, particularly any money? Is it to be turned back to the rightful owner, and if so, how can you determine that? Is it to be used for helping the citizens rebuild the country, and if so, who determines which people receive aid? Is there an oversight committee?
Superheroes
Superhero movies seem to have a whole lot of destruction. Who fixes everything after the supervillain is defeated? Where do the funds come from? Insurance companies? State or federal governments? Who buys the new cars, fixes the roads, and rebuilds the buildings? Is counseling offered for those people held hostage by the supervillain? How does one deal with that sort of thing? Who fixes the security leaks? Can they be fixed?
Science Fiction
In my experience, this genre deals the best with questions about the aftermath of a bad government being toppled (see in particular Elizabeth Moon). There are pirates who either show up or grow stronger with less organized military resistance. Communication between planets becomes more of an issue. There tends to be a redistribution of power. There are people very unhappy about losing. Firefly explores this a bit from the other side.
Just a few thoughts. There may eventually be a story out of these thoughts, but right now I'm just mulling things over.
Fantasy
So many heroes go on a quest, defeat the Dark Lord, and the story ends (more or less happily). After the Dark Lord has been defeated, then what? Who builds the country again? Most of these Dark Lords also have Dark Armies. If it is some sort of nasty that is morally bad (e.g. Tolkien's orcs), who hunts them down and kills them? If the army is composed, instead, of humans or some free-willed creatures, who decides who is good and who is bad? Are there military tribunals? To what degree is the army responsible for the actions ordered by the Dark Lord or his lieutenants? If there were many people pressed into military service, which ones were they (men, women, young, middle-aged, some mixture) and what effect has this had on the culture? What happens when these people go back? Are some of the military roving bands of outlaws, now?
If there is a rightful ruler, is he or she accepted by the general population? Is there an old constitution or declaration of rights that can be accepted, or does it have to be thought up from scratch? Who is in charge of this? Are there any judges, lawyers or politicians who weren't corrupted by the Dark Lord who can help, and if so, how can you tell if they've been corrupted or not? Has the Dark Lord mostly left local politics in place, or has he or she put their own people in charge everywhere? If so, has he or she merely deposed the good people, or killed them? Are there any bands of outlaws that are actually good (like Robin Hood), and how does one distinguish them from the nasty sort of outlaws, and having distinguished them, how does one bring them back into society?
Was there any other country whose army helped depose the Dark Lord? Will they expect some sort of reparations or such? Whose authority will they accept regarding a peace treaty? Are they leaving any occupying forces?
Has the Dark Lord accumulated gold or supplies at their fortress? What happens to these things, particularly any money? Is it to be turned back to the rightful owner, and if so, how can you determine that? Is it to be used for helping the citizens rebuild the country, and if so, who determines which people receive aid? Is there an oversight committee?
Superheroes
Superhero movies seem to have a whole lot of destruction. Who fixes everything after the supervillain is defeated? Where do the funds come from? Insurance companies? State or federal governments? Who buys the new cars, fixes the roads, and rebuilds the buildings? Is counseling offered for those people held hostage by the supervillain? How does one deal with that sort of thing? Who fixes the security leaks? Can they be fixed?
Science Fiction
In my experience, this genre deals the best with questions about the aftermath of a bad government being toppled (see in particular Elizabeth Moon). There are pirates who either show up or grow stronger with less organized military resistance. Communication between planets becomes more of an issue. There tends to be a redistribution of power. There are people very unhappy about losing. Firefly explores this a bit from the other side.
Just a few thoughts. There may eventually be a story out of these thoughts, but right now I'm just mulling things over.